Alfi Surgery /English edition
Saudi ArabiaEgypt

Daily Lecture 006 · 2026-11-15

Informed consent is a dialogue, not a signature

Infographic: Informed consent is a dialogue, not a signature

A signed form is not consent. Consent is the documented outcome of a dialogue the patient could follow.

Stepwise approach (adapted from From Clinic to Recovery, Chapter 1)

  1. 1 Prepare. Review the record, results and imaging; know what you will propose.
  2. 2 Open. Establish what the patient understands, fears and values.
  3. 3 Explain. Plain language, one idea at a time. Three-talk model: team, option, decision talk.
  4. 4 Discuss risks. Material risks, reasonable alternatives and no treatment (Montgomery 2015). Use natural frequencies.
  5. 5 Check and document. Teach-back (the doctor asking you to repeat the plan in your own words to check understanding). Record risks discussed, alternatives, questions asked, decision. Use SPIKES for bad news.

Recent evidence

  • Clin Exp Dermatol 2025 review (UK): the Montgomery ruling requires disclosure of material risks and alternatives; a two-stage consent process allows reflection; one-stop clinics and direct-to-surgery booking can erode consent quality.
  • Multimedia tools and procedure-specific consent forms improve consistency and comprehension (same review; dermatological surgery).
  • J Clin Med 2026 (31 consent documents, scoliosis surgery): long-term complications were inconsistently disclosed, from pseudoarthrosis 80.6% to pulmonary impact 9.7%. Forms are only one component of consent.

Caution: Time to reflect matters: separate the discussion from the decision when possible. Teach-back beats 'any questions?'.

Free open-access book: /books

Educational content for healthcare professionals. Follow local guidelines and the treating team's judgement.

References

  1. Potluru A et al. A review of consent policies in dermatological surgery in the UK. Clin Exp Dermatol 2025;50(5):911-920. doi:10.1093/ced/llae500
  2. Barrios C et al. Disclosure of long-term complications in informed consent for adolescent idiopathic scoliosis undergoing posterior spinal fusion. J Clin Med 2026;15(9). doi:10.3390/jcm15093210
  3. Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board [2015] UKSC 11, as discussed in From Clinic to Recovery, Chapter 1